Thank you for calling that out, you are absolutely right.
Toggling -NoCrawl:$false
via PowerShell does not trigger a reindex if the site is already set to allow crawling. It's a common misconception, and I appreciate you highlighting that nuance.
To ensure legacy content is picked up by the crawler and subsequently detected by the Data Classification Service, the recommended approach is to explicitly trigger a reindex using one of the following:
Best Practice - Use SharePoint UI
Go to Site Settings --> Search and Offline Availability --> Click Reindex Site
This action guarantees a full reprocessing of the site's content, independent of existing crawl settings.
For Automation - Use PnP PowerShell
Connect-PnPOnline -Url <SiteURL> -Interactive
Request-PnPReindexWeb -Force
This is a more reliable method than toggling crawl settings and works well for scripted or automated workflows.
Summary
Best Practice – Use the SharePoint UI Reindex Site button for simplicity and reliability.
Automation – Use Request-PnPReindexWeb
if you need to integrate reindexing into a script or pipeline.
By reindexing via either method, legacy content will be rescanned, detected by Purview’s Data Classification Service, and labeled according to your service-side auto-labeling policies.
Thanks again for surfacing this - it's an important distinction that helps clarify how reindexing is actually triggered.
I hope this information helps. Please do let us know if you have any further queries.
Thank you.